Replace Modi, with Whom?

Recently, I came across two articles. One by Chetan Bhagat and the other by Tavleen Singh. Both Bhagat and Singh are neither blind supporters nor are they ideologically opposed critics of Narendra Modi lead BJP government at the center. Thus, opinion they express carries weight. According to both of them, Narendra Modi is becoming unpopular in the country and there is a widespread discontent among small and mid size businessmen and common people. More importantly, the gap between Mr. Modi and his chief opponent Mr. Rahul Gandhi has reduced to a considerable extent.

It is true Modi had received a massive support of voters. Many has lamented that government has frittered away the mandate. One has to understand that many ministers in government probably are not in tune with Modi’s idea of India. They would rather win election by giving short term subsidies and move on. Besides, though government had majority in Lok Sabha, in the upper house government did not have numbers. Thus many proposals of government faced opposition in the upper house.

There are several key efforts that government has tied to make. They include:

  • Modi government has tried to alter social behaviour of Indians. Ideas like clean India and protection and education of a girl child were not new. Uniqueness was never before such admission made by any prime minister from the ramparts of red fort.
  • Based on the ideology of his party, government has tried to reach the bottom of the pyramid. Zero balance bank account, direct transfer of benefits, supply of gas connection, universal healthcare benefits are testimony to this effort.
  • Government has also made investment in creating road connectivity, improve rail services, remove corruption in government purchases etc.

Yet, I think one of the greatest negatives of Modi is his silence when innocent muslims were killed by cow vigilantes. And, many perpetrators of crime were not even brought to book. Even if we argue that law and order is a state subject, as a prime minister of India, Modi should have expressed his grief and shared his pain with victims of lynching. Many sensible development oriented Hindus shudder at the events and statements that emerged thereafter.

The question of re-election of Modi has been discussed many a time and probably many more projections will be made till 2019. Modi was elected in 2014 because of the vision he shared with Indian electorate. Election after election, post 2014, has seen that voters seem to buy into Modi’s dream of a new and different India. Thus, despite high unemployment, high fuel price, erratic implementation of GST, and inconvenience during months of demonitisation, we cannot count Modi out.

Will Modi win a second term, only time and electoral arithmatic may tell. There is no doubt, India is divided on her opinion on Modi and his performance. While a large section believes, Modi is dedicated, honest and an ideal person to bring some sense in unruly polity. On the other an equally large number believes Modi is dictatorial and must be removed. It is upto our increasingly aware Indian people, young and old, male and female, to ask who or what will they replace Modi with? Yes Modi has his faults, yet is it bigger than advantage his replacements will offer?

Does this mean we may see Mr. Rahul Gandhi as prime minister of India in 2019? Given the quirks of Indian politics, one cannot rule the possibility out. Who knows, it could be behenji Mayawati or Mamata didi. May be Mr. Deve Gowda will come out of his retirement to save India. Compulsion of coalition politics is a great term used to defeat a common enemy in the name of saving democracy. The result would be weakest person may become prime minister, because every constituent of the coalition may have an opportunity to flex his muscle and get his demand met.


If not Narendra Modi then who could be India’s next PM?

7 thoughts on “Replace Modi, with Whom?

Add yours

  1. Well written!! Not a blind supporter of any but if I see the scenario Rahul Gandhi have got political status on the basis of sliver spoon and it’s a field which doesn’t run on the benefits of silver spoon!! Modi have taken a good turn on the development of the country but yes with few mistakes and one of them is bias thoughts on religion . BJP was often criticised on that thoughts which often led them with poor votes. With few thought changes and working beyond rigid habits country needs a good leader like Modi !!


    1. Modi has many faults. But what does others offer? Is Mamata or, Mayawati better or different? Yes cow related violence has gone up. I do not like any innocent man being killed for any reason. But for seventy years why have situation not changed?

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I definitely agree!! I suppose rather than supporting anyone blindly one should bring faults ahead giving the scope of improvement as for now our country needs a good leader!! As said we really have no option than one person!!
        More over blind believes and illiteracy is leading our country in to huge problem and hampering our progress!! Religion definitely divides and successfully doing that!! Leaving a big question mark on diversity.
        Hamper of Freedom of speech and expression and freedom to religion both major points in constitution have truly been effected in recent times!!
        I wish the citizens understand and bring improvement on their own believes before we blame anyone

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: